The Answer Is A Question
The Easy Way to Quickly Transform Your Impact as a Manager and Leader
by Laura Ashley-Timms & Dominic Ashley-Timms
“I have transformed the way I communicate. One of the best investments in career learning that I’ve made. It serves as a daily guide to my success as a manager.”
Most managers rise through the ranks because they excel at delivering answers. Yet the very habit that wins early promotions eventually blunts impact. When a boss reflexively prescribes, three side effects creep in: employees disengage ("Why think if the boss already knows?"), organizational learning stalls, and blind spots multiply. The Answer is a Question flips the script. Authors Laura Ashley and David Booth (both executive coaches and former Fortune 100 leaders) contend that sustained success depends less on the brilliance of your solutions and more on the quality of your questions. Inquiry, they insist, is a force-multiplier: it unearths information, builds trust, and ignites creativity at scale.
The Neuroscience of Curiosity
The book opens with a glance inside the brain. MRI studies show that open-ended questions activate the dopaminergic reward network—the same circuitry that makes us crave puzzles or cliff-hangers. When leaders ask colleagues to explore "What might we be missing?" or "How else could this work?", they release a hit of dopamine that sharpens focus and fuels collaborative energy. Conversely, handing down directives triggers a compliance mindset: people do the minimum needed, then wait for the next order. By understanding this neurochemical toggle, managers see why a single well-timed question can raise the collective IQ of a meeting.
The Question-First Framework
Ashley and Booth distill years of coaching into a three-step loop, easy to remember yet deep enough to guide any interaction:
Frame the Aim – Before speaking, clarify the outcome you want. Is it learning, alignment, or decision?
Ask With Intention – Pose a concise, open question that invites reflection rather than a binary yes/no.
Listen, Reflect, Release – Hold space for the answer, mirror key points to prove you heard them, and resist the urge to re-seize control.
Run the loop repeatedly and conversation turns into a co-design session, not a quiz.
Five Questioning Habits of High-Impact Leaders
High-impact communicators speak from curiosity instead of certainty. They open with phrases like "I'm wondering…" or "Help me understand…," signaling genuine interest. When things go wrong, they keep the focus on future learning instead of fault-finding: "What can we carry forward from this setback to the next sprint?" They start wide to surface hidden angles ("What options haven't we explored?") before drilling into promising threads. Silence becomes a tool; counting to five after asking a question lets deeper insights surface. Finally, they echo and elevate—paraphrasing what they hear and linking it back to the broader mission so contributors feel seen and purpose-connected.
Curiosity over Certainty – Begin discussions with "I'm wondering…" or "Help me understand…" to signal genuine interest.
Future over Fault – Replace blame-seeking with possibility-seeking. Ask, "What can we learn from this mishap for the next sprint?"
Breadth before Depth – Start wide to surface unseen angles ("What options haven't we explored?"), then drill into promising leads.
Silence as Tool – Count to five after asking; silence invites deeper thought and often surfaces the most valuable insights.
Echo and Elevate – Paraphrase responses ("So you're concerned about rollout timing") and connect them to the larger mission to reinforce meaning.
Each habit turns everyday exchanges—stand-ups, performance reviews, even hallway chats—into micro-labs of collective intelligence.
Designing High-Octane Questions
Not all inquiries are created equal. The authors supply a checklist:
Open-ended: Starts with how, what, or why—not do, is, or can.
Focused: Targets a single theme rather than cramming multiple queries into one breath.
Non-leading: Avoids smuggling in a preferred answer ("Don't you think we should…?").
Purpose-linked: Connects to stakes the listener cares about.
Stretch + Safety: Challenging enough to spark new thinking, yet framed without judgment so people feel safe to answer honestly.
A leader might transform "Can you finish this by Friday?" into "What would it take for us to deliver meaningful progress by Friday—and what support would best help you get there?" The latter surfaces constraints, resource needs, and ownership in one swoop.
Using Questions to Navigate Core Managerial Moments
During performance feedback, old-school managers announce deficiencies; question-leaders begin with self-assessment: "When you watch the playback, where do you feel strongest, and where could you grow?" In conflict mediation, instead of dictating peace, they ask each side, "What underlying needs feel unmet right now?" Strategic planning kicks off not with a PowerPoint of predefined targets but with an expansive prompt: "If we build a product our future selves will be proud of, whose problems are we solving, and how will the world be different?"
Performance Feedback
Old way: "You need to improve your presentation skills."
Question-first way: "When you watch the playback, what parts of your presentation feel strongest, and where do you see room to grow?" Self-assessment precedes guidance; employees become partners in their own development plan.
Conflict Mediation
Old way: "Apologize and move on."
Question-first way: "What underlying needs does each side feel are unmet right now?" Shifting focus from positions to interests opens pathways to win-win solutions.
Strategic Planning
Old way: Execs issue a five-year plan.
Question-first way: Start the kickoff by asking, "If we create a product our future selves would be proud of, what problems are we solving, and for whom?" The question reframes planning as exploration rather than edict.
Building a Question-Centered Culture
One leader's behavior sparks change, but institutional habits sustain it. Teams that embrace inquiry start meetings with a focusing question circulated in advance, ensuring attendees arrive primed. Dashboards place a "learning question" column next to every KPI so metrics fuel exploration, not just reporting. Recognition programs spotlight employees whose questions saved money or sparked new revenue, making curiosity a path to prestige. Even onboarding teaches newcomers the question-first loop so inquiry feels normal from day one. Over time, the organization shifts from knowledge hoarding to knowledge sharing, accelerating its ability to adapt.
Meetings begin with a single "focusing question" circulated in advance, ensuring everyone arrives primed.
Dashboards include a "Learning Questions" column next to KPIs, reminding teams to track what they're discovering, not just what they're delivering.
Recognition Programs spotlight employees who asked a question that led to significant savings or innovation, signaling that curiosity wins kudos.
Onboarding trains newcomers in the question-first loop, normalizing inquiry from day one.
Over time, the organization shifts from knowledge-hoarding to knowledge-sharing, accelerating adaptation in fast-moving markets.
Breaking the Answer Reflex
Knowing the theory is easy; fighting the adrenaline rush of "I know the answer!" is hard. Ashley and Booth suggest micro-habits:
Bite Your Tongue Rule – In the first ten minutes of a team problem-solving session, the manager speaks last.
Question Tokens – Enter meetings with three tokens; you must ask three questions before expressing any opinion.
Post-Mortem Journaling – After interactions where you defaulted to telling, jot what question you could have asked instead. The reflection rewires future behavior.
Dealing with Pushback
Some team members may read questioning as indecision. Combat this by pairing inquiry with context: "I have initial thoughts, but I want to hear yours first so we can stress-test all angles." Others may fire back, "Just tell us what to do." That's a cue to explain benefits: "If I impose the plan, you'll execute. If we craft it together, you'll own it—and that ownership will show in results."
Integrating Data and Expertise
The book is not anti-answer. Expertise matters. The trick is timing. Leaders should unleash questions to map the terrain, then plug in knowledge at moments where it genuinely adds value. Think GPS: ask for landmarks, then overlay expert maps to plot the best route. This sequencing preserves empowerment while still leveraging senior insight.
Thirty Days to a Question-Powered Leadership Style
Ashley and Booth close with a month-long practice plan. Begin by tracking how often you give answers versus ask questions, aiming for parity by Friday of week one. In week two, rewrite daily directive emails into question-led coaching notes and compare the response quality. Week three calls for scripting three strategic questions for a high-stakes meeting and practicing silent counts after each one. In the final week, share the framework with your team, invite them to hold you accountable, and rotate the role of "chief questioner" in meetings so inquiry becomes everyone's habit.
Week 1 – Awareness
Track conversations; note how often you give answers versus ask questions. Aim for a 1:1 ratio by Friday.
Week 2 – Skill Building
Every day, rewrite one directive email into a question-led coaching email. Compare response quality.
Week 3 – High Stakes Deployment
Choose a critical meeting—budget review or client pitch. Script three strategic questions and practice silent counts after asking.
Week 4 – Culture Seeding
Share the framework with your team, invite them to hold you accountable, and rotate the role of "chief questioner" in meetings.
What Changes When Questions Lead
Companies that institutionalize inquiry report faster decision cycles, because information surfaces early instead of after failed implementation. Employee engagement scores rise, driven by a sense of psychological safety. Innovation metrics improve as oddball ideas get airtime. And managers reclaim bandwidth: rather than firefighting every issue, they coach teams to solve problems independently.
Final Reflection
The Answer is a Question is neither anti-expertise nor anti-direction. It is a manifesto for balance: direct when stakes require it, inquire whenever growth is possible. By mastering the subtle art of asking—then truly listening—leaders convert authority into influence, subordinates into co-creators, and ordinary meetings into arenas of discovery. In an era where competitive advantage hinges on learning faster than the environment changes, the ability to ask catalytic questions may indeed be the missing superpower that changes everything.
Business Floss is reader-supported. When you use our links we may earn an affiliate commission that helps us keep the site running. Thank you for your support!
