Who
The A Method for Hiring
by Geoff Smart & Randy Street
The 60-Second Take
In Who, Geoff Smart and Randy Street dismantle the costly, instinct-driven practices they call "voodoo hiring." They argue that finding the right people is the single most important problem a business faces. By replacing vague job descriptions with rigorous Scorecards and implementing a structured four-step process—Source, Select, and Sell—leaders can consistently hire "A Players" and eliminate the massive financial and cultural drain of a bad hire.
Why Your Gut Instinct Is Ruining Your Team
If you ask a room full of executives what their most expensive business problem is, they will usually point to a failed product launch, a shifting market, or a lost client. In Who, Geoff Smart and Randy Street argue that these are merely symptoms. The root cause of almost every business failure is a "who" problem. You hired the wrong person to build the product, manage the market, or talk to the client. The authors estimate that the average hiring mistake costs a company fifteen times the employee's base salary in wasted time, lost productivity, and toxic cultural fallout.
Despite these massive stakes, the authors found that most managers approach hiring with shocking amateurism. They rely on "voodoo hiring" methods. They act as the "Art Critic," making snap judgments based on a candidate's handshake. They act as the "Prosecutor," trying to stump candidates with irrelevant logic puzzles. They act as the "Sponge," letting six different employees interview a candidate with zero coordination or shared criteria.
Who offers a cure for this costly guesswork. Based on thousands of hours of interviews with billionaires, CEOs, and investors, Smart and Street developed the "A Method for Hiring." It is a rigid, highly structured four-step process—Scorecard, Source, Select, and Sell—designed to systematically identify and secure "A Players." This summary breaks down the mechanics of how to build a hiring machine that actually works.
What You'll Learn
The definition of an "A Player" and why settling for "B Players" destroys teams
Why traditional job descriptions fail, and how to build an outcome-driven Scorecard
How to use the Topgrading Interview to uncover a candidate's true track record
The "Threat of Reference Check" technique to force candidates to tell the truth
The "5 Fs" required to successfully sell a high performer on joining your company
Step 1: The Scorecard
The first reason managers make bad hires is that they do not actually know what they are looking for. They draft generic job descriptions filled with meaningless corporate jargon—"must be a team player," "requires excellent communication skills," "five years of experience." The A Method replaces the job description with a Scorecard.
A Scorecard is a document that describes exactly what a person must accomplish in the role. It is divided into three parts: the Mission, Outcomes, and Competencies.
The Mission is a short, plain-English summary of the job's core purpose. The Outcomes are the three to eight specific, measurable goals the person must achieve by the end of their first year. If a traditional job description says, "Manage the sales team," a Scorecard Outcome says, "Increase outbound sales revenue from $1M to $2M by Q3." Finally, the Competencies list the specific behavioral traits required to achieve those outcomes, such as "relentless persistence" or "high attention to detail." By defining the outcomes before you even look at a resume, you create an objective measuring stick to evaluate every candidate against. Your goal is to hire an "A Player"—defined by the authors as someone who has at least a 90 percent chance of achieving the outcomes on your Scorecard.
Step 2: Source
Most companies treat hiring as an emergency. A vital employee resigns, panic sets in, and HR scrambles to post a job listing online. By relying almost entirely on incoming resumes, you limit yourself to the people who happen to be looking for a job at that exact moment. Often, the best talent is not looking; they are happily employed and highly valued by your competitors.
To hire A Players, you have to build a continuous sourcing machine. The authors emphasize that the absolute best source for top talent is referrals from your professional and personal networks. You should make it a habit to constantly ask your top performers, your vendors, and your mentors a single, recurring question: "Who are the most talented people you know that I should hire?" By cultivating these relationships before you have an open headcount, you build a bench of pre-vetted talent that you can tap the moment a need arises.
Step 3: Select (The Four Interviews)
The heart of the A Method is the "Select" phase, which replaces unstructured, conversational interviews with a rigid sequence of four specific meetings.
The first is the Screening Interview. This is a short, 30-minute phone call designed to weed out obvious mismatches. You ask what they are looking for, what they are best at, what they are worst at, and—crucially—who their previous bosses were and how those bosses would rate them on a scale of 1 to 10.
If they pass, they advance to the Topgrading Interview. This is the core engine of the A Method. It is an exhaustive, chronological walk-through of a candidate's entire career. Starting from their education, you ask five questions about every single job they have held:
What were you hired to do?
What accomplishments are you most proud of?
What were some low points during that job?
Who were the people you worked with (and how will your boss rate you when we call them)?
Why did you leave that job?
This interview can take several hours. By moving chronologically, patterns emerge. If a candidate claims they left three different jobs because their manager was "toxic," you have identified a behavioral red flag.
Next is the Focused Interview, where you bring in other team members. Instead of having them ask random questions, you assign each interviewer a specific Outcome or Competency from the Scorecard to drill down on. Finally, you conduct the Reference Interview. The authors insist that you must conduct these yourself, and you must use the names the candidate provided during the Topgrading interview. References are notoriously hesitant to say anything negative, so you have to listen carefully to what they do not say, and push for specifics.
Step 4: Sell
Identifying an A Player is useless if you cannot convince them to take the job. High performers are in demand, and they are interviewing you just as rigorously as you are interviewing them. Smart and Street outline the "5 Fs" that you must address to effectively sell a candidate on the role.
Fit: Show the candidate how their specific skills and career trajectory perfectly align with the company's vision and the Scorecard's outcomes.
Family: Address the collateral impact of the job change. Acknowledge that changing jobs affects their spouse, children, and lifestyle, and do everything you can to accommodate those needs.
Freedom: A Players hate being micromanaged. Assure them that because the outcomes on the Scorecard are clear, they will have the autonomy to execute the work their way.
Fortune: Ensure the financial compensation is highly competitive and properly linked to the performance outcomes.
Fun: Communicate the culture. High performers want to work in an environment where they are challenged, respected, and surrounded by other highly competent people.
Crucially, the selling phase does not just happen at the offer stage. You must be selling the candidate during the sourcing phase, throughout every interview, when the offer is extended, and for their first hundred days on the job to ensure they do not experience buyer's remorse.
The A Method at a Glance
Voodoo hiring. Relying on gut instinct, unstructured conversations, or trick questions leads to a 50 percent failure rate.
The Scorecard. Replace generic job descriptions with a document that defines the specific, measurable outcomes the person must achieve in year one.
A Players. A candidate who has a 90 percent chance of achieving the outcomes on your Scorecard. You should never settle for a B or C Player.
Continuous Sourcing. Build a pipeline of talent before you need it by constantly asking your network for referrals.
The Topgrading Interview. A rigorous, chronological walk-through of the candidate's entire career history to uncover patterns of success or failure.
The Threat of Reference Check (TORC). Telling a candidate upfront that you will be contacting their previous bosses forces them to answer interview questions honestly.
The 5 Fs of Selling. To land top talent, you must sell them on Fit, Family, Freedom, Fortune, and Fun.
A Quick Start Guide to Hiring A Players
Draft a Scorecard immediately. Before you interview another person, write down three to eight specific, measurable outcomes that define absolute success for the role.
Mine your network. Ask your top three employees today: "Who is the most talented person you know that we should hire?"
Implement the TORC. In your very first screening call, ask the candidate for their previous manager's name and ask how that manager will rate them out of 10 when you call.
Conduct chronological interviews. Stop jumping around a resume. Force the candidate to walk you through their career from the beginning, explaining exactly why they left every single role.
Call the references yourself. Do not outsource reference checks to HR. Call the previous managers directly and ask, "What is the candidate's biggest area for improvement?"
Who Should Read Who (and Who Can Skip It)
Read it if you are a founder, executive, or hiring manager tired of the financial and emotional exhaustion of firing people who never should have been hired in the first place.
Read it if your company currently relies on "culture fit" interviews where teams ask random questions and make decisions based on subjective likability.
Read it if you want a highly prescriptive, operational manual that gives you the exact scripts and questions to use in an interview.
Skip it if you are an entry-level professional seeking advice on how to pass an interview and get hired; this book is written exclusively from the perspective of the employer.
Skip it if you want broad, theoretical ideas about corporate culture or leadership philosophy. This is a tactical, nuts-and-bolts methodology book.
Final Reflections
Who: The A Method for Hiring is arguably the most practical book written on talent acquisition in the modern era. Geoff Smart and Randy Street successfully demystify the hiring process, proving that evaluating human capital does not require a magical intuition. It requires a rigorous, disciplined process. The book's greatest strength is its absolute intolerance for vagueness. By forcing managers to define exact outcomes (the Scorecard) and interrogate a candidate's actual history (the Topgrading Interview), the authors eliminate the cognitive biases that lead to terrible hires. While implementing the full A Method requires a significant upfront investment of time and energy, the book convincingly proves that the cost of doing it right is minuscule compared to the devastating cost of doing it wrong.
The Bottom Line
Hiring based on gut instinct is a guessing game that destroys companies, so you must replace it with a rigorous system that defines measurable outcomes and chronologically interrogates a candidate's actual track record.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main idea of Who: The A Method for Hiring? The main idea is that "voodoo hiring"—relying on gut instinct and unstructured interviews—causes a massive failure rate. To consistently hire top talent ("A Players"), businesses must adopt a structured four-step process: building an outcome-based Scorecard, systematically Sourcing talent, Selecting candidates via rigorous chronological interviews, and properly Selling them on the role.
What is a Scorecard? A Scorecard is the authors' replacement for a traditional job description. Instead of listing generic traits and required years of experience, a Scorecard explicitly details the Mission of the role, the specific, measurable Outcomes the person must achieve in their first year, and the behavioral Competencies required to get there.
What is a Topgrading Interview? It is the core of the selection process. Instead of asking random behavioral questions ("Tell me about a time you failed"), the interviewer asks the candidate to walk through every job in their career chronologically, answering specific questions about what they were hired to do, their accomplishments, their failures, and exactly why they left.
Business Floss is reader-supported. When you use our links we may earn an affiliate commission that helps us keep the site running. Thank you for your support!
