Good to Great
Why Some Companies Make the Leap… and Others Don't
by James C. Collins
“Jim Collins’ carefully researched and well-written book, Good to Great, is a must-read for any executive or business leader who wants to understand how to create a superior company.”
The Unbreakable Laws of Business Greatness: A Guide to the 'Good to Great' Framework
Why do some companies make the leap to enduring greatness while others, starting in the exact same industry with the same opportunities, just plod along as "good" companies? Is it a matter of luck? A single visionary leader? A killer new technology? For years, the business world was filled with opinions, but no real data. Then, business researcher Jim Collins and his team embarked on a monumental five-year study to find the answer.
They sifted through decades of data on 1,435 companies, looking for a very specific pattern: firms that had 15 years of average, "good" stock market performance, followed by a transition point, and then at least 15 years of "great" performance, crushing the market average. They found only 11. Each of these "good-to-great" companies was then compared against a similar company that failed to make the leap. The result of this exhaustive research was the landmark book, Good to Great. It’s not a collection of theories; it's a data-backed blueprint of the timeless, and often counterintuitive, principles that separate the truly great from the merely good.
What You'll Learn
The surprising personality traits of the most effective leaders (hint: it's not charismatic celebrity CEOs).
Why who you hire is far more important than what your strategy is.
A simple, three-circle framework for finding your company's unique path to greatness.
The difference between a "flywheel" of unstoppable momentum and a "doom loop" of mediocrity.
The power of confronting the most brutal facts of your reality while never losing faith.
Disciplined People: The Foundation of Greatness
Collins discovered that the journey to greatness doesn't start with a new vision or strategy. It starts with people.
Level 5 Leadership
The first, and perhaps most surprising, finding was the type of leader at the helm of every great company. They weren't high-profile, celebrity CEOs with larger-than-life egos. Instead, they were Level 5 Leaders—individuals who possessed a paradoxical blend of deep personal humility and intense professional will.
They were modest, reserved, and even shy, consistently giving credit to their teams and looking out the window to attribute success to others. But when it came to their work, they were fanatically driven, with an unwavering resolve to do whatever it took to make the company great. Darwin Smith, the CEO who transformed the mediocre paper company Kimberly-Clark into a world leader, was a perfect example. He was a mild-mannered, in-house lawyer who, upon becoming CEO, displayed an iron will, selling off the company's traditional mills to bet everything on the consumer paper goods market. He was humble in personality but ferocious in his ambition for the company.
First Who, Then What
Once a Level 5 leader was in place, their first priority was not to figure out the strategy. It was to get the "right people on the bus, the wrong people off the bus, and the right people in the right seats." Collins uses the powerful analogy of a bus. He found that the great companies focused on assembling a team of disciplined, self-motivated people first. Only then did they figure out where to drive the bus.
The logic is simple: if you start with "who," you can easily adapt to a changing world. If you have the right people, the problem of how to motivate and manage them largely goes away. A friend who runs a fast-growing tech company took this to heart. She passed on hiring a supposedly brilliant but arrogant engineer because he was a "wrong person for the bus." Instead, she hired a less experienced but incredibly determined and collaborative developer. The "brilliant" engineer's next company was plagued by infighting, while my friend's team, full of the "right people," built a phenomenal culture and product.
Disciplined Thought: Facing Reality and Finding Your Focus
With the right people on board, the next phase is about developing a deep and honest understanding of your reality and your unique strengths.
Confront the Brutal Facts (The Stockdale Paradox)
Collins found that the good-to-great companies had an unwavering commitment to facing the truth, no matter how harsh. He named this concept the Stockdale Paradox, after Admiral Jim Stockdale, who survived for years as a prisoner of war in Vietnam. Stockdale observed that the optimists—the ones who kept saying "we'll be out by Christmas"—were the first to die of a broken heart.
The ones who survived were those who accepted the brutal reality of their situation while, at the same time, maintaining an unshakable faith that they would prevail in the end. Good-to-great companies do the same. They create a climate of truth where facts are heard and debated, allowing them to make better decisions.
The Hedgehog Concept
This is arguably the most famous concept from the book. It’s based on an ancient Greek parable: "The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing." The fox is cunning and tries many complex strategies to attack the hedgehog, but the hedgehog always wins by doing its one big thing perfectly: rolling into a spiky ball.
Collins found that great companies operate like hedgehogs. They find the one thing they do better than anyone else and focus on it with relentless consistency. Your "Hedgehog Concept" is found at the intersection of three circles.
Finding Your Hedgehog: The Three Circles of Greatness
A clear Hedgehog Concept is not a goal or a strategy; it's a deep understanding. To find yours, you must answer three questions with brutal honesty. Greatness lies at the intersection of the answers.
What can you be the BEST in the world at? This is not what you want to be best at, but what you have the potential to actually be the world's best at. It requires a realistic self-assessment of your capabilities.
What drives your economic engine? You need to understand the single key metric that has the greatest impact on your profitability. For Walgreens, it was profit per customer visit. By focusing on this, they made decisions (like adding convenient drive-thru pharmacies) that maximized their core economic driver.
What are you deeply passionate about? Great companies are filled with people who are genuinely passionate about the work they do. This passion provides the fuel to persevere on the long road to greatness.
Disciplined Action: The Flywheel and the Breakthrough
The final piece of the puzzle is how greatness actually happens. Collins found that it was never a single, dramatic event. There was no miracle moment, no single killer innovation, no revolutionary program.
Instead, the process resembled relentlessly pushing a giant, heavy flywheel. The first few turns are incredibly difficult and require immense effort for almost no visible movement. But with consistent, disciplined pushing in a single direction, the flywheel begins to build momentum. Push after push, turn after turn, it spins faster, until it hits a point of breakthrough, where its own weight does the work and it seems to fly forward.
This is how good-to-great transformations happen: through the cumulative effect of thousands of small, disciplined decisions and actions, all aligned with the Hedgehog Concept.
The comparison companies, in contrast, were stuck in the Doom Loop. They would try one big new program, fail to see immediate results, and then lurch in a completely new direction with a new leader or a new strategy. This constant, reactive motion prevented them from ever building the kind of unstoppable momentum that defines a great organization.
Final Reflections
Good to Great is not a simple checklist for overnight success; it is a profound and disciplined framework for building an organization that endures. Jim Collins's research provides a powerful and evidence-backed argument that greatness is not born from circumstance but from conscious choice and disciplined action. By embracing the paradox of Level 5 Leadership, getting the right people on the bus, confronting the brutal facts, discovering your unique Hedgehog Concept, and relentlessly pushing the flywheel, any leader can begin the long but rewarding journey from being merely good to becoming truly great.
Business Floss is reader-supported. When you use our links we may earn an affiliate commission that helps us keep the site running. Thank you for your support!