How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make the Competition Irrelevant
by W. Chan Kim & Renée Mauborgne
The 60-Second Take
In Blue Ocean Strategy, INSEAD professors W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne argue that the best growth comes from creating uncontested market space rather than fighting rivals in crowded markets. Drawing on a study of 150 strategic moves across more than 100 years and 30 industries, they introduce value innovation, the strategy canvas, the four actions framework, the six paths, and tipping point leadership. The tools are practical and widely used in strategy workshops, though the examples are chosen in hindsight and blue oceans eventually attract competitors.
Stop Competing and the Trade-Off Disappears
Most strategy asks how to beat the companies you're competing with. W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne ask a different question: what if competing head-on is the problem?
Their metaphor divides markets into two types. Red oceans are existing industries with known boundaries and accepted rules. Companies fight over a fixed pool of demand, and as competition intensifies, profits shrink and the water turns bloody. Blue oceans are uncontested market spaces where new demand is created and competition is, at least for a time, irrelevant.
Kim and Mauborgne, professors at INSEAD and codirectors of its Blue Ocean Strategy Institute, published Blue Ocean Strategy in 2005, with an expanded edition in 2015. The book rests on a study of 150 strategic moves spanning more than 100 years and 30 industries. Their central finding challenges a basic assumption of strategy. This summary covers that idea, the tools built around it, and the book's limits.
What You'll Learn
The difference between red and blue oceans
Why value innovation rejects the trade-off between cost and differentiation
How to use the strategy canvas to see an industry's assumptions
How the four actions framework reshapes an offering
Six paths for finding uncontested market space
How to reach noncustomers and lead strategic change
Value Innovation
The book's core idea rejects a familiar trade-off. Traditional strategy holds that a company must choose between low cost and differentiation, because standing out usually costs money. Kim and Mauborgne argue that this is true only when companies compete on the same factors as everyone else in their industry.
Value innovation is the pursuit of differentiation and low cost at the same time. Companies achieve it by changing the factors they compete on. Eliminating and reducing features the industry takes for granted lowers costs. Raising and creating features nobody offers increases value for buyers. The savings help fund the new value.
Cirque du Soleil, founded in 1984, is the book's signature example. Traditional circuses competed on animal acts, star performers, and multiple rings, all expensive and declining in appeal. Cirque removed those, improved the venue and artistic quality, and created storylines, original music, and themed productions. The result cost less to run and sold at theater prices to adults who had stopped attending circuses.
Another example is the Australian wine brand [yellow tail]. In an industry focused on vintages, complex flavors, and prestige, Casella Wines created a simple, easy-drinking wine with fun branding. It appealed to beer and cocktail drinkers who found wine intimidating, and it became one of the fastest-growing wine brands in the United States after its 2001 launch.
The authors cite other examples as well. NetJets created fractional jet ownership, combining the convenience of a private jet with a cost closer to first-class travel. Curves built fitness centers for women who found traditional gyms intimidating, eliminating mirrors, showers, and complex equipment in favor of a quick, social workout circuit.
The Strategy Canvas
The book's main diagnostic tool is the strategy canvas. It lists the factors an industry competes on along the horizontal axis and the level offered on the vertical axis. Plot your company and its competitors, and you get value curves.
The usual result is revealing: everyone's curves look nearly the same. Companies believe they're differentiated, but they're competing on the same factors with minor variations. That's a red ocean, which explains why margins are under pressure and price wars are common.
Kim and Mauborgne identify three traits of a strong strategic profile. Focus means the curve emphasizes a few key factors instead of offering a little of everything. Divergence means it looks clearly different from competitors. A compelling tagline means the strategy can be captured in a short, honest message.
The Four Actions Framework
To create a new value curve, the authors pose four questions:
Eliminate. Which factors the industry takes for granted should be removed?
Reduce. Which factors should be reduced well below the industry standard?
Raise. Which factors should be raised well above the industry standard?
Create. Which factors should be created that the industry has never offered?
The authors organize these into the eliminate-reduce-raise-create grid. The grid forces companies to answer all four questions. Most organizations naturally focus on raising and creating, because adding feels safer. Eliminating and reducing are harder, but that's where cost savings come from. A strategy that only adds features becomes a more expensive version of what already exists.
The Six Paths Framework
To find blue oceans systematically, Kim and Mauborgne offer six paths, each challenging a different boundary.
Look across alternative industries. Consider industries that serve the same need in different ways, such as movie theaters and restaurants competing for an evening out.
Look across strategic groups. Examine different tiers within an industry, such as luxury and budget options, and combine their strengths.
Look across the chain of buyers. Purchasers, users, and influencers often have different priorities.
Look across complementary products and services. Consider what happens before, during, and after customers use a product.
Look across functional or emotional appeal. Industries that compete on function may find opportunity in emotion, and vice versa.
Look across time. Identify trends already underway and ask how they'll change the market.
Reaching Noncustomers
Kim and Mauborgne argue that blue oceans often lie among noncustomers. They describe three tiers. The first tier are "soon-to-be" noncustomers who buy minimally and would leave if they found a better option. The second tier are "refusing" noncustomers who have consciously chosen not to buy. The third tier are "unexplored" noncustomers who have never considered the industry at all.
Asking why these people don't buy often reveals more opportunity than asking existing customers what they want added. The authors encourage companies to look for commonalities among noncustomers, since shared reasons for not buying can point toward a large pool of untapped demand.
Getting the Strategic Sequence Right
The authors recommend testing a blue ocean idea in a specific order: buyer utility, price, cost, and adoption. First, ask whether the offering delivers exceptional utility to buyers. Next, set a price that's accessible to the mass of target buyers. Then work backward to a cost that allows profit at that price. Finally, address adoption hurdles among employees, partners, and the public.
Execution: Tipping Point Leadership and Fair Process
The book also addresses execution. Tipping point leadership focuses on the small number of people, actions, and resources that have outsized influence on an organization. The authors use Bill Bratton's turnaround of the New York City Police Department in the 1990s as an example.
Bratton faced what the authors call four organizational hurdles. The cognitive hurdle is getting people to see that change is needed; he made senior officers ride the subway to experience conditions firsthand. The resource hurdle is limited budgets; he concentrated resources on the areas with the greatest impact. The motivational hurdle is energizing staff; he focused on key influencers and made performance highly visible. The political hurdle is overcoming powerful opponents; he enlisted allies and silenced critics early. The broader lesson is that leaders don't need to change everything at once. They need to find the points of greatest leverage.
Fair process argues that people accept difficult change when they're engaged in decisions, understand the reasoning behind them, and know what's expected afterward.
Blue Ocean Strategy at a Glance
Red vs. blue oceans. Crowded markets versus uncontested space.
Value innovation. Pursue differentiation and low cost together.
Strategy canvas. Reveal how similar competitors really are.
Four actions. Eliminate, reduce, raise, and create.
Six paths. Look across boundaries for new opportunities.
Noncustomers. Ask why people don't buy.
A Quick Start Guide to Applying Blue Ocean Strategy
Draw your strategy canvas. Plot your company and two competitors.
Start with eliminate. List what your industry offers out of habit.
Talk to noncustomers. Ask why they don't buy.
Work one of the six paths. Explore one boundary in depth.
Test your tagline. State your strategy in one clear phrase.
Who Should Read Blue Ocean Strategy (and Who Can Skip It)
Read it if you compete in a crowded market and want an alternative to price wars.
Read it if you run strategy workshops and need practical visual tools.
Read it if you want a counterpoint to Michael Porter's competitive strategy.
Skip it if your main challenge is execution rather than positioning.
Skip it if you already know the core vocabulary and tools.
Final Reflections
Blue Ocean Strategy endures because its tools are practical. The strategy canvas often shows executives that their supposedly differentiated companies compete on the same factors as everyone else. The eliminate question is one many strategy processes never ask, since organizations are built to add. Readers interested in positioning products in crowded markets may enjoy Obviously Awesome, and those mapping how a new model creates and captures value can turn to Business Model Generation.
The book has limits, though. Its examples are chosen because they succeeded, so readers don't see the companies that tried similar moves and failed. Blue oceans also turn red as imitators arrive, and the book says less about defending a position than creating one. Its tension with Michael Porter, who argues that trade-offs make positions defensible, is worth holding rather than resolving. Value innovation happens, but it's harder and rarer than the book's confident tone suggests.
The Bottom Line
The trade-off between low cost and differentiation exists only while you compete on inherited industry factors, so eliminate what customers don't value and invest in what nobody offers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is value innovation?
The pursuit of differentiation and low cost at the same time, achieved by changing the factors a company competes on.
What is the four actions framework?
Four questions for reshaping an offering: what to eliminate, reduce, raise, and create. Eliminating and reducing lower costs, while raising and creating add value.
What are the six paths?
Six ways to find uncontested markets: look across alternative industries, strategic groups, buyer groups, complementary offerings, functional or emotional appeal, and time.
Business Floss is reader-supported. When you use our links we may earn an affiliate commission that helps us keep the site running. Thank you for your support!